Page 337 of 342 of Document 134 in LEX-29913
Dear Department of Agriculture Fisheries & Forestry,
I request Document 134 in LEX-29913 to be released in full - https://www.agriculture.gov.au/sites/def...
In particular the page is titled "INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT - REPORT TO GOVERNMENT BY 30 SEPTEMBER 2023" claims a s 47C(1) exemption.
(1) A document is conditionally exempt if its disclosure under this Act would disclose matter ( deliberative matter ) in the nature of, or relating to, opinion, advice or recommendation obtained, prepared or recorded, or consultation or deliberation that has taken place, in the course of, or for the purposes of, the deliberative processes involved in the functions of:
(a) an agency; or
(b) a Minister; or
(c) the Government of the Commonwealth.
The redaction under "Implementation options to explore could include:" in the document does not fit this criteria.
As the OAIC states:
"'Deliberative matter’ is a shorthand term for ‘opinion, advice and recommendation’ and ‘consultation and deliberation’ that is recorded or reflected in a document.
At the time the document was created that list of "options to explore could include" is for a panel that had yet to be formed or selected. According to their published TOR, the panel were able to determine their own approach to their task. They were appointed on an "Independent" basis and not subject to any directions within that document. There were no parts of that document the panel were required to consider. (TOR link below)
As such, at the time of creation it was not a deliberative matter that was for an agency, a Minister, the Government of the Commonwealth. No one was required to consider it and no decision was to be made from it.
As the OAIC advice states "if the material was obtained BEFORE there was a known REQUIREMENT that the material WOULD be considered during a deliberative process, that material would not be deliberative matter."
There was and remains, no "requirement" to consider that section of the document. The language is clear - "options to explore COULD include". As there is no requirement for that part of the document to be considered, the exemption cannot be relied upon.
It was merely something a panel may wish to explore in the future, which comes under "purely factual" material and not any matter under deliberation. There is also no evidence that this list was provided to the panel.
Given the Panel's independence, 6.66 in the OAIC guide is made out and it was not "matter that was not obtained, prepared or recorded in the course of, or for the purposes of, a deliberative process."
Please release the document in full.
Yours faithfully,
SF
Panel TOR - https://www.agriculture.gov.au/sites/def...
Dear SF
Acknowledgement of your Freedom of Information Request No: LEX 30317
I refer to your request, received by the Department of Agriculture,
Fisheries and Forestry on 3 October 2023 for access to documents under the
Freedom of Information Act 1982 (FOI Act) made in the following terms:
‘'I request Document 134 in LEX-29913 to be released in full -
In particular the page is titled "INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT - REPORT TO
GOVERNMENT BY 30 SEPTEMBER 2023" claims a s 47C(1) exemption.'
Your address
The FOI Act requires that you provide us with an address which we can send
notices to. You have advised your electronic address is
[1][FOI #10729 email]. We will send all notices
and correspondence to this address.
Please advise us as soon as possible if you wish for correspondence to be
sent to another address or if your address changes. If you do not advise
us of changes to your address, correspondence and notices will continue to
be sent to the address specified above.
Disclosure log
Please note that information released under the FOI Act may be published
in a disclosure log on the department's website. Section 11C of the FOI
Act requires this publication, however it is subject to certain
exceptions, including where publication of personal, business,
professional or commercial information would be unreasonable.
Exclusion of junior department employee details
The department is working towards ensuring that all employees have a
choice about whether they provide their full name and direct contact
details in response to public enquiries. Where such details are included
in the scope of a request, this may add to processing time and applicable
charges as it may be necessary to consider whether the details are exempt
under the FOI Act. On this basis, unless you tell us otherwise, we will
assume that these details are out of scope of your request and they will
be redacted under section 22 of the FOI Act.
Further assistance
If you have any questions please email [2][email address].
Regards,
FOI Contact Officer | Legal Division
E: [3][email address]
___________________________________________
Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry
GPO BOX 858 CANBERRA ACT 2601
This email and any attachments may contain information subject to legal
professional privilege or information that is otherwise sensitive or
confidential. If you are not the intended recipient of this email, you are
prohibited from using or disseminating this communication. If you have
received this communication in error please notify the sender immediately
and permanently delete this email.
------ IMPORTANT - This email and any attachments have been issued by the
Commonwealth of Australia (Commonwealth). The material transmitted is for
the use of the intended recipient only and may contain confidential,
legally privileged, copyright or personal information. You should not
copy, use or disclose it without authorisation from the Commonwealth. It
is your responsibility to check any attachments for viruses and defects
before opening or forwarding them. If you are not an intended recipient,
please contact the sender of this email at once by return email and then
delete both messages. Unintended recipients must not copy, use, disclose,
rely on or publish this email or attachments. The Commonwealth is not
liable for any loss or damage resulting from unauthorised use or
dissemination of, or any reliance on, this email or attachments. If you
have received this e-mail as part of a valid mailing list and no longer
want to receive a message such as this one, advise the sender by return
e-mail accordingly. This notice should not be deleted or altered ------
References
Visible links
1. mailto:[FOI #10729 email]
2. mailto:[email address]
3. mailto:[email address]
Dear Foi,
I would like to note that the document requested was discussed at senate estimates.
Relevantly the minister said as per Hansard:
Senator Watt: I don't think it would be fair, and we're not necessarily doing this, but it's not as if the
department was giving me advice that these are the things we should do.
It is clear that the minister did not consider the briefing this to be deliberative material.
No response required, but please take this into account when providing a decision.
Yours sincerely,
SF
Dear SF
Please find attached correspondence in relation to your FOI request – LEX
30317.
Kind regards
FOI Contact Officer | Legal Division
E: [1][email address]
___________________________________________
Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry
GPO BOX 858 CANBERRA ACT 2601
This email and any attachments may contain information subject to legal
professional privilege or information that is otherwise sensitive or
confidential. If you are not the intended recipient of this email, you are
prohibited from using or disseminating this communication. If you have
received this communication in error please notify the sender immediately
and permanently delete this email.
------ IMPORTANT - This email and any attachments have been issued by the
Commonwealth of Australia (Commonwealth). The material transmitted is for
the use of the intended recipient only and may contain confidential,
legally privileged, copyright or personal information. You should not
copy, use or disclose it without authorisation from the Commonwealth. It
is your responsibility to check any attachments for viruses and defects
before opening or forwarding them. If you are not an intended recipient,
please contact the sender of this email at once by return email and then
delete both messages. Unintended recipients must not copy, use, disclose,
rely on or publish this email or attachments. The Commonwealth is not
liable for any loss or damage resulting from unauthorised use or
dissemination of, or any reliance on, this email or attachments. If you
have received this e-mail as part of a valid mailing list and no longer
want to receive a message such as this one, advise the sender by return
e-mail accordingly. This notice should not be deleted or altered ------
References
Visible links
1. mailto:[email address]
Dear Department of Agriculture Fisheries & Forestry,
Please pass this on to the person who conducts Freedom of Information reviews.
I am writing to request an internal review of Department of Agriculture Fisheries & Forestry's handling of my FOI request 'Page 337 of 342 of Document 134 in LEX-29913'.
There is still too much not disclosed here.
For example, the title of page 5 claims a s 47C(1) exemption. I find it difficult to accept that the title of a page contains deliberate material. Even accepting the reasoning of the previous decision maker, information on 'what' the minister was briefed on is not deliberative material. All titles and headings should be released. These are not "opinion, advice or recommendation obtained". Even if somehow they are, it is in the public interest to know the matters the department is briefing the minister on (even if an exemption is claimed on the substance of that advice or option). Knowing what the department is briefing the minster could not prejudice any government process.
Page 5 also has 4 boxes under "What we are hearing". Assumedly, there is a 5th box there with a title and content. Assuming the content is titled correctly, the missing "What we are hearing" box would also be classed as factual information. 47C(b) specifically excludes factual information as being deliberative.
All s 47C claims should be reviewed against whether they are deliberative, factual and if public interest claims are appropriate.
The claims for 47F exemptions are accepted and do not need to be further explored.
Yours faithfully,
SF
Dear SF
Acknowledgement of Internal Review no: IR 30317
The Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (the Department)
acknowledges receipt of your application for internal review under the
Freedom of Information Act 1982 (FOI Act) dated 10 November 2023.
The statutory deadline for providing a decision on this request is
currently 11 December 2023.
We will contact you at this email address. Please advise if you would
prefer us to use an alternative means of contact.
If you have any questions, please contact [1][email address].
Regards
Kind regards
FOI Contact Officer | Legal Division
E: [2][email address]
___________________________________________
Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry
GPO BOX 858 CANBERRA ACT 2601
This email and any attachments may contain information subject to legal
professional privilege or information that is otherwise sensitive or
confidential. If you are not the intended recipient of this email, you are
prohibited from using or disseminating this communication. If you have
received this communication in error please notify the sender immediately
and permanently delete this email.
------ IMPORTANT - This email and any attachments have been issued by the
Commonwealth of Australia (Commonwealth). The material transmitted is for
the use of the intended recipient only and may contain confidential,
legally privileged, copyright or personal information. You should not
copy, use or disclose it without authorisation from the Commonwealth. It
is your responsibility to check any attachments for viruses and defects
before opening or forwarding them. If you are not an intended recipient,
please contact the sender of this email at once by return email and then
delete both messages. Unintended recipients must not copy, use, disclose,
rely on or publish this email or attachments. The Commonwealth is not
liable for any loss or damage resulting from unauthorised use or
dissemination of, or any reliance on, this email or attachments. If you
have received this e-mail as part of a valid mailing list and no longer
want to receive a message such as this one, advise the sender by return
e-mail accordingly. This notice should not be deleted or altered ------
References
Visible links
1. mailto:[email address]
2. mailto:[email address]
Dear SF
Please find attached correspondence from the Department of Agriculture,
Fisheries and Forestry in relation to your request for internal review
IR-30317.
Kind regards
FOI Contact Officer | Legal Division
E: [1][email address]
___________________________________________
Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry
GPO BOX 858 CANBERRA ACT 2601
This email and any attachments may contain information subject to legal
professional privilege or information that is otherwise sensitive or
confidential. If you are not the intended recipient of this email, you are
prohibited from using or disseminating this communication. If you have
received this communication in error please notify the sender immediately
and permanently delete this email.
------ IMPORTANT - This email and any attachments have been issued by the
Commonwealth of Australia (Commonwealth). The material transmitted is for
the use of the intended recipient only and may contain confidential,
legally privileged, copyright or personal information. You should not
copy, use or disclose it without authorisation from the Commonwealth. It
is your responsibility to check any attachments for viruses and defects
before opening or forwarding them. If you are not an intended recipient,
please contact the sender of this email at once by return email and then
delete both messages. Unintended recipients must not copy, use, disclose,
rely on or publish this email or attachments. The Commonwealth is not
liable for any loss or damage resulting from unauthorised use or
dissemination of, or any reliance on, this email or attachments. If you
have received this e-mail as part of a valid mailing list and no longer
want to receive a message such as this one, advise the sender by return
e-mail accordingly. This notice should not be deleted or altered ------
References
Visible links
1. mailto:[email address]