Referencecode:7FTS3QWR
Information
Commissioner
Review
Applicationform
Gettingstarted
TheOfficeoftheAustralianInformationCommissionercanreviewa
FreedomofInformation(FOI)decisionmadebyanAustralian
GovernmentagencyoranAustralianGovernmentMinister.
TheOfficedoesnotreviewFOIdecisionsmadebyState,Territoryor
localgovernmentagencies.
TheOfficeencouragesyoutoapplyforaninternalreviewbythe
agencybeforelodgingarequestforreviewwiththisOffice.Information
relatingtotheinternalreviewprocess
(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/reviews/internal-
review/)isavailableonourwebsite(https://www.oaic.gov.au/).
TheInformationCommissionerhasgivenageneraldirectionunders
55(2)(e)(i)oftheFOIActwhichsetsouttheproceduretobefol owed
byapplicantsforICreviewsundertakenbytheInformation
CommissionerundertheFOIAct.Toviewthedirection
(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/reviews/direction-as-
to-certain-procedures-to-be-fol owed-by-applicants-in-information-
commissioner-reviews)andthe‘Quickguide’
(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/reviews/quick-guide-
information-commissioner-review-direction-for-applicants),pleasevisit
ourwebsite.
InformationrelatingtotheInformationCommissionerreviewprocess
(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/reviews/information-
commissioner-review-process/)isavailableonourwebsite.Part10of
theFOIGuidelines(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-
information/foi-guidelines/part-10-review-by-the-information-
commissioner/)(ReviewbytheInformationCommissioner)describes
theprinciplesthatinformtheOAIC’sapproachtoInformation
Commissionerreview.
Anapplicationforreviewmustbesubmittedinwriting,eitherviathis
form,anemail,orinaletter.Ifyouhavetroublecompletingthisform
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx@xxxx.xxx.xx.
Yourdetails-ICreviewapplicant
IfyouhavecontactedtheOAICpreviouslyaboutthisoranothermatter,
pleaseprovideyourpreviousreferencenumber(egE11/00001,MR18/00001)
Title
Givenname *
Familyname *
B
Z
Preferredcontactmethod(youmustprovideatleastonecontactmethod) *
Email
Phone
Post
Other
Emailaddress *
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx.xx
Phone(daytime)
Mobile
Includeareacode
Postaladdress
Starttypingful addresshere.
Othercontactdetails(eg.faxorinternationaladdress)
xx.xxxxxxxxxxxx@xxxxxx.xx
DoyourequireanyassistancetoparticipateintheICreviewprocess?
Forexample:aninterpreter.Pleasedetailbelow.
Doyouhavesomeoneyouwouldliketorepresentyouinyourreview? *
Yes
No
Reviewdetails
AgencyorMinister
PleaseselecttheAustralianGovernmentagencyorMinisterthatmadethedecisionyouwantreviewed.Ifyouwantmorethanone
decisionreviewed,youwillneedtomakeaseparateapplicationforeachdecision. *
AustralianGovernmentAgency
Minister
Agencyinformation
PleaseselecttheAustralianGovernmentAgencythatmadethedecisionyouwantreviewed *
AdministrativeAppealsTribunal
Attorney-General'sDepartment
AustralianFederalPolice
AustralianSecuritiesandInvestmentsCommission
AustralianTaxationOffice
AustralianTransactionReportsandAnalysisCentre
OfficeoftheCommonwealthOmbudsman
DepartmentofAgriculture,FisheriesandForestry
DepartmentofClimateChange,Energy,theEnvironmentandWater
DepartmentofDefence
DepartmentofEducation
DepartmentofEmploymentandWorkplaceRelations
DepartmentofForeignAffairsandTrade
DepartmentofHealthandAgedCare
ServicesAustralia
DepartmentofHomeAffairs
DepartmentofIndustry,ScienceandResources
DepartmentofInfrastructure,Transport,RegionalDevelopment,CommunicationsandtheArts
DepartmentofthePrimeMinisterandCabinet
DepartmentofSocialServices
DepartmentoftheTreasury
DepartmentofVeterans'Affairs
Other
OtherAustralianGovernmentAgency *
APSC
Previouscontactwithagency
IftheagencyhasgivenyouareferencenumberrelevanttoyourFOIrequest,pleaseprovideithere.
LEX954
NOTE:Wedonotneedtoknowyourtaxfilenumber,sopleasedonotprovideit.
InformationCommissionerreviewdetails
Haveyoureceivedadecision *
Yes
No
TomakeavalidapplicationforICreviewyoumustsendusacopyofthedecisionyouwantreviewed.Ifadecisionisnotprovided,your *
applicationmaynotbevalid.*
Filesyouattach
must:
bein*.jpg,*.gif,*.png,*.pdf,*.doc,*.docx,*.txt,*.xls,*.xlsxformat
benomorethanfivefilesintotalbe
nolargerthan20MB.
LEX954876IRdecisionsigned.pdf
LEX876Document.pdf
Isthedecisionthatyouareseekingreviewofanoriginaldecisionoraninternalreviewdecision? *
Originaldecision
Internalreviewdecision
Whenwasthedecisionmade? *
15May2024
InmostcasesyoumustapplyforICreview(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/foi-guidelines/part-10-review-by-the-
information-commissioner/#application-for-ic-review)within60daysofbeingnotifiedoftheMinister’soragency’sdecisiontorefuse
accesstodocuments(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/foi-guidelines/part-10-review-by-the-information-
commissioner/#access-refusal-decisions).Youmustapplywithin30daysifyouarerequestingreviewofadecisiontograntaccessto
documentstoanotherperson(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/foi-guidelines/part-10-review-by-the-information-
commissioner/#access-grant-decisions).
YoucanalsoasktheInformationCommissionertograntyoumoretimetoapplyforICreview.
IsyourapplicationforICreviewbeingmadewithintheabovetimeframes?*
*
Yes
No
IamseekingICreviewbecausetheAgencyorMinister(morethanoneoptioncanbeselectedifappropriate):*
refusedaccesstodocumentsorpartsofdocumentsIrequested
Advisescopeofreview.*
Pleaseprovideasummaryofwhichexemption/syoudisagreewithandprovidereasonswhyyoudisagree.
Arethereanyparticulardocuments(notingdocumentorfolionumber)thatyouwouldlikereviewed?
Theexemptionsthatdonotapplyaress47E(c)and47E(d)and47F.
Ihaveprovidedareasonableexplanationastowhythoseexemptionsdonotapplyintheinternalreviewrequest:
https://www.righttoknow.org.au/request/document_lex_695#outgoing-22739
Irelyonthosesubmissionsinmyinternalreviewrequest.
AsInotedinmyinternalreviewrequest,alessredactedversionofthePIDreporthasbeenreleasedundertheFOIActandis
accessibletothepublic:
https://archive.org/download/pid-2020-400006-december-2020-kate-mc-mullan-report-issued-under-s-51-of-the-pid/PID-2020-
400006%20-%20December%202020%20-%20Kate%20McMullan%20-
%20Report%20issued%20under%20s%2051%20of%20the%20PID%20Act%202013%20%28Cth%29%20into%20allegations%20of
%20misconduct%20in%20the%20Federal%20Court%20and%20correspondence.pdf
ThereisnopointinrefusingaccesstothePIDreportsinceitisalreadypublicinformation.
Therearemanynewspaperarticlesabouttheerrorsinthereport.TherearealsoFOIdecisionsfromtheAPSCthatshowthatthe
investigationwasnotproperlyconducted:
LEX510:https://docdro.id/QjLA2Jf
LEX511:https://docdro.id/ycu9G2N
LEX520:https://docdro.id/bWc6ohv
LEX547:https://docdro.id/UiVKH0f
LEX550:https://docdro.id/oDK0cPC
IalsonotethatthesubmissionsinMelanieMcIntyre'sdecisionletterare,legallyspeaking,incorrect.Iwouldliketomakedetailed
submissionsonthematterwhentheopportunityarises.
refusedaccessbecauseapracticalrefusalreasonexists
refusedaccessbecausedocumentscannotbefound
deferredaccesstodocumentsIrequested
refusedtomakecorrectionstomypersonalinformation
decidedtoreleaseinformationaboutmeormybusiness.
chargedmeincorrectly
grantedaccesstodocumentsbutIhavenotreceivedthem
grantedaccesstoaqualifiedpersonandnotdirectlytome
refusedtoextendthetimeformetoseekaninternalreview
grantedaccesstodocumentsthatIwasconsultedabout
grantedaccesstodocumentsthatmybusinesswasconsultedabout
Pleaseprovideasummaryofwhyyouthinkthedecisioniswrong *
Pleaseseeabove.
Ifyouwouldlikereviewofthepersonalprivacyexemption(s47F),doyouhaveconsentofthethirdparty/ieswhoseinformationyou
seek
Yes
No
Submission
Submittingyourapplicationforreview
Pleasereviewtheinformationyouhaveprovidedinthisform.Ifyouwouldliketochangeanything,youcan
returntotherelevantsectionbyusingthe
GoBackbutton.
Onceyouarereadytosubmityourform,clickthe
Submitbuttonbelow.
Onceyousubmityourform,youwil betakentoaconfirmationpage.Thispagewil provideareceipt
numberforyoursubmission,andyouwil beabletodownloadacopyofyourcompletedformorhavea
copysenttoanemailaddressofyourchoice.
FurtherinformationabouttheInformationCommissionerreviewprocess
(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/foi-guidelines/part-10-review-by-the-information-
commissioner/),includingaboutwhathappenswhenanInformationCommissionerreviewapplicationis
made(https://www.oaic.gov.au/freedom-of-information/foi-guidelines/part-10-review-by-the-information-
commissioner/#steps-in-the-information-commissioner-review-process),canbefoundonourwebsite
(https://www.oaic.gov.au/).
